Repair or replace your AC?
If you are holding a repair quote, this is the only question that matters. Put the number in and see the arithmetic, not just a verdict.
Should you repair or replace?
At 15 years, replacement is usually the better spend.
- Your system is about 15 years old. In Houston a system runs far more hours per year than the national average, so equipment here reaches the end of its usable life earlier than national guidance suggests.
- Past about 10 years, a ac compressor replacement rarely pays for itself. The rest of the system is the same age and the next failure is not far behind.
A full replacement in Houston would run about $8,960 to $14,000.
This is an estimate, not a quote. Correct sizing comes from a Manual J load calculation that accounts for your insulation, windows and orientation. Ask any contractor for theirs in writing.
How the comparison works
A repair buys the remaining life of the system, not a fresh start. So the fair comparison is cost per remaining year against cost per year of a new system across its full life. A $2,400 compressor on a system with three years left is $800 a year. A new system at $11,000 over fifteen years is about $730 a year, with a warranty and lower running costs attached. That is why big repairs on old systems lose even when the sticker price looks so much smaller.
Three things that override the math
- R-22. Out of production since 2020 and only available as reclaimed stock at punishing prices. Any repair opening the refrigerant circuit on an R-22 system is money into equipment that is already at least fifteen years old.
- A failed compressor out of warranty. The most expensive part in the system, on a system old enough for the part to fail, is close to a replacement decision by itself.
- Repeat failures. Two service calls in one season is the system telling you what the next few years look like.
Your city
Common questions
- Is it worth repairing a 15 year old AC unit in Texas?
- Usually not. At fifteen years a Texas system has accumulated far more run hours than the same unit would elsewhere, the remaining life is short, and a large repair now does not reduce the replacement cost later.
- What is the repair versus replace rule?
- Compare the repair cost per remaining year against a new system cost per year across its full life. If the repair approaches the new system figure, replacing is the better buy despite the much larger sticker price.
- How long do AC units last in Texas?
- Twelve to eighteen years, and Texas systems land in the lower half. Cooling season runs most of the year here, so equipment wears at a pace national lifespan figures were not built around.